Social Studies or ELA?

Social Studies teachers and English Language Arts teachers often use the same documents, but in different ways. Below is a list of tasks or activities that ask students to address a document. In which classroom would each be appropriate?

Sort them by dragging each task into the appropriate column. If you prefer, you can also do this activity using a form with radio buttons. Some browsers may work best with (or show only) one or the other format; use the one that works best for you.

Activities Which Classroom?
Social Studies English Language Arts
Students are asked to read like a discipline-specific expert such as a geographer, historian, or economist.
Students are asked to read the text and make connections to how the sourcing (who the writer of the document is) affects the intent of the document.
Students are asked to read like a writer.
Students are asked to focus on who the writer/author of the document is and how who they are reflects in the intent in writing the document.
Students are asked to focus on reading to learn the facts presented in the documents only.
Students are asked to focus on causation separate from the intention of the document or the writer themselves.
Students are asked to focus on causation that is due to human intention and human action.
Students are asked to read the text to understand how specific rhetoric devices are used by a writer.